HomeMy WebLinkAbout10.A.1. Presentation by Shakopee Chamber of Commerce of a Request to Study the City's Sign Ordinance 1 0.A•1. 1
CITY OF SHAKOPEE
Memorandum
TO: Mayor and City Council
Mark McNeill, City Administrator
FROM: R. Michael Leek, Community Development Director
SUBJECT: Discussion of Chamber of Commerce (Chamber) Public Policy Committee (PPC)
Recommendation Regarding 2012 Sign Ordinance Study (Chamber Study)
MEETING DATE: November 7, 2012
ACTION SOUGHT:
Offer and pass a motion directing city staff to continue with updating the current City of Shakopee sign
regulations.
BACKGROUND:
At its meetings in September and October, the EDAC heard the discussion regarding the Chamber
study related to City sign regulations. A similar presentation is also made to the Shakopee Planning
Commission on October 4, 2012.
The EDAC indicated that it was in favor of reviewing the City's sign regulations. The Planning
Commissioners also indicated that they were in favor of reviewing the City's sign regulations. The
Planning staff has begun assembling information from the cities that were specifically mentioned in the
Chamber of Commerce September 4th letter (attached). In addition, Community Development Director
Michael Leek heard a presentation at the recent Minnesota APA conference by a planner with the City
of Duluth regarding that city's recent overhaul of its sign regulations. A copy of the draft Duluth sign
ordinance also accompanies this report.
Chamber of Commerce President Angie Whitcomb and EDAC member /Chamber Public Policy
Committee chair Kevin Wetherille have requested the ability to present the Chamber study to the City
Council at its November 7 meeting.
RECOMMENDATION:
Both the Planning Commission and Economic Development Advisory Commission (EDAC) have
recommended that the City proceed with a review and update of the City's sign regulations.
RELATIONSHIP TO VISIONING:
This item relates to Goal D, "Maintain, improve and create strong partnerships with other public and
private sector entities."
H:ACC \2012 \11- 7 \11072012_Sign Study_2.doc
2
BUDGET IMPACT:
There is no direct budget impact, other than staff time.
ACTION REQUESTED:
If the Council concurs, it should, by motion, direct city staff to continue to work to update the City's
current sign regulations as outlined in the Chamber study or otherwise. Council is also asked to
provide direction regarding whether July 2013 is the appropriate timeframe for the update to reach
the City Council for consideration.
J
R. Michael Leek
Community Development Director
H:ACC \2012 \11- 7 \11072012_Sign Study_2.doc
Chamber &
V�ors Bureau
Shakopee — Minnesota
September 4, 2012
City of Shakopee
Economic Development Advisory Commission
RE: 2012 Sign Ordinance Study
Dear EDAC Members,
In early 2012, the Shakopee Chamber of Commerce, through its Public Policy Committee (PPC) em
study to examine the current Shakopee sign ordinance to see how it was impacting local businesses.
project was the result of Chamber members voicing concerns about the ordinance. Initial research r
the majority of the current ordinance was adopted well before the recent boom in retail and commer
development in Shakopee. For these reasons, the PPC initiated a study to examine the current ordin
this report, we present the findings of that study.
The Process
The first step in the process was to divide the ordinance up into relevant sections and assign a comet
member or two to each section. Those members then reviewed that section and made an informal re
group on that section. Second, the PPC held three (3) public open house events. The events were of
for business owners, citizens, and public officials to discuss the existing ordinance. The event locati
chosen to try and reach the various retail and residential areas of the City. One was held at the polic
department, one at Turtle's and one in Southbridge. Following this information gathering, the PPC
reviewed ordinances from other municipalities to compare them to Shakopee.
The following cities were among those examined: Bloomington, Apple Valley, Woodbury, Chanha
Prairie, Savage, and Lakeville.
The Findings
At the conclusion of this study, the following themes repeated themselves:
1) The current ordinance is difficult to navigate, both in print and online.
2) Businesses along the 169 corridor feel the ordinance is very restrictive. In Southbridge area,
the business park is not clearly visible from the highway. Most believe the sign height requii
too low for highway areas. The same concerns were raised to the East of Marschall Road on
the Dean Lakes area.
3) We heard from developers that national chains have declined bringing retail business to Shall
because of the sign ordinance. Builders shared that many national chains have a checklist of
exploring potential sites. Because their "standard" signage does not meet the Shakopee ordii
Shakopee is taken off the list of potential locations.
{ ��I ; III !�f I_ �'j
� 1 l
1 j i 1 01 1 ' t.("nttiit i Ro td 1 1 4 ` �l alto t 55 "� s ' ' ,i
I ! Y t. p� e, �11`� >.�r) u�vev.sl' zal,�l� c,c..cjr
j I 111,0110: 9W,,-.4;15 U • h:tx: 0�.�. ,145-1 I • I 1 o ll 1 tit s: 1 t t�� - 44 ;21i5t I 4
1
Chamber &
Q(isitors Bureau
Shakopee — Minnesota
4) The temporary sign regulations are difficult to navigate. Some areas allow it, some don't. Many are
concerned about special short-term business promotions (sidewalk sales, food specials) running afoul of
the ordinance.
5) Many Multi -tenant property owners and managers felt the ordinance is very restrictive on them. Both
for on building signage as well as free - standing signage.
6) Monument sign regulations are too restrictive re: size, number and location on lot.
7) Electronic message signs: there was a desire to utilize new sign technologies that are prohibited by the
ordinance. Topics discussed included change frequency, brightness level, dimming and motion control
of varying electronic signs.
8) Overall, it was felt that the current ordinance made businesses visibility difficult in many commercial
areas in Shakopee.
9) Fear that any changes to older signs (that are grandfathered in) will result in City applying more
restrictive guidelines or not allowing sign at all.
10) In recreational areas, there is a desire to be allowed to advertise with promotional banners.
11) Historical buildings felt very limited in allowable signage due to setback requirements, etc.
12) The variance /CUP process is not a business - friendly alternative for most small and medium businesses.
National chains simply won't go through the process in general, will choose a city that is more amenable
to their signage requirements. Process is expensive, and outcome often unknown.
13) A number of Downtown businesses would like to work with the City to develop a way to provide more
visible signage from Hwy 101 to increase visibility of downtown retail area.
14) Regulations that make sense for some areas (i.e. historical downtown) don't make sense for others
(Dean Lakes). The ordinance should be tailored specifically to the unique needs of the businesses in
each business area.
15) Shakopee lacks strong directional signage directing customers to the various retail centers in town
(particularly those not visible from 169).
16) Almost all attendees agree that the ordinance should promote quality, attractive signage and not sacrifice
the overall aesthetics of the community.
17) Thcre was some concern raised about whether historical marker signage is allowed in Shakopee. An
example of this is found in Carver where historical buildings have landmark signs on them. These signs,
if allowed, would help create and enhance an historical perspective in certain parts of Shakopee.
Possible Solutions:
Following the informational gathering exercise, the PPC met and discussed some possible solutions to
address concerns heard from Shakopee businesses.
1) Develop a graphic presentation such as a table or chart with basic requirements for each zone. Examples
of this are found in Savage and Chanhassen. Improves navigability of ordinance and organization of
regulation.
2) Consider implementing a "highway overlay district" for the 169 corridor. This area would have
regulations that are tailored specifically to the needs of those businesses. Perhaps this could include
taller and larger allowable signs yet require higher quality. For example, Woodbury allows larger
signage along freeway frontage.
3) Consider including visual examples of allowable styles of signage. Example: Woodbury, Chanhassen.
4) Implement a "master signage plan" ordinance. An example is found in Apple Valley. The concept
encourages the business /developer to think forward on signage needs for each particular development,
• k fi
.a " 180,1 fast C punty °Road 101 + Shakopee. MN ::379 • www.shakopee.org '
l ' 3 d ; Phone; 052-1454660 • Fax. 952445 -1669 • Isoli -Feu: 1.800.574 -2150
Chamber&
Visitors Bureau
Shakopee — Minnesota
and allows more signagc (25% increase) over otherwise allowable space for those electing to engage in
a master signage plan. Master plan goes through the planning and approval process, and can be
modified over time, but only upon application. Allows City to have input on aesthetics, while allowing
the business interest more flexibility. In Apple Valley, it also reduced the size of the sign ordinance
significantly. To make this attractive to businesses /owners, the City must sufficiently incentivize the
process by allowing greater sign usage in areas that seek such approval.
5) Develop a clearer temporary signage policy. Consider allowing special promotion signage to retail and
commercial businesses more easily and frequently. The PPC liked how Apple Valley handled this, they
allow special promotion signage (sidewalk sales, etc.) with a permit. The application for the permit is
free. There is a short handout on those requirement and it is very easy to navigate. Allow the
applications online to speed the process.
6) Re- evaluate maximum sign height requirement in areas where there are significant variations in grade
due to roadways, etc. The main area would be along the elevated, and lowered, stretches of 169.
7) Consistent enforcement. Currently, Shakopee has very limited enforcement of the sign ordinance which,
in turn, has created a feeling of confusion among business operators. One city, Eden Prairie, uses a
"tab" permit system where conforming signs receive a small sticker indicating conformance with the
ordinance. This makes non - conforming, non - permitted signs more readily visible.
8) Make Ordinance more searchable. Consider making it possible to view just the portion of the ordinance
relevant to each district, as opposed to the whole document.
9) Build more flexibility and predictability into the ordinance for businesses seeking a variance, and clearly
address concerns over fees that come with signage permits.
10) Retool the electronic sign section.
11) Consider loosening regulations on historical signs to recognize the historical nature of certain areas and
properties in Shakopee.
Action Steps:
The business community, through the Shakopee Chamber, would like to see City staff commence a
comprehensive review of the sign ordinance that takes into consideration the current demands of the varying
business centers in town, the desire of the City to be an economic development leader, and the need for
reasonable sign regulation. It is hoped that the information and suggestions in this report will provide a
roadmap for that process. The PPC respectfully requests that City staff engage stakeholders in the process as
appropriate. The suggestion is to involve the EDAC, the Chamber, SCALE and others as appropriate. The
Shakopee Chamber of Commerce hopes that changes can be made to the ordinance that are ready for Council
consideration by July 2013.
18111 last County Ililat1 tot 5511c) • www %m&;
I'lttliir 9r12 1.15- 161.;O • 1 "? 44!)-I60 • roll 1
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
Note: Figure numbers to be added to public hearing draft. Certain tables may also be reformatted.
50 -27.1 Permit Required
A. All signs that require a permit, as described in Section 50 -27.5 (Sign Types - Permit Required) must obtain
a zoning permit as described in Section 50 -37.13 (Zoning Permit) of this Unified Development Chapter.
B. When submitting a zoning permit application for a sign, the applicant must submit photographs and
dimensions of all signs existing on the lot, including all signs that will be removed. The City may request that
the applicant submit photographs of all new signs erected on the lot after permit issuance.
C. The applicant must sign the zoning permit application attesting to the accuracy of the information provided.
The City may revoke any sign permit where there has been a violation of the provisions of this section or
misrepresentation of fact on the zoning permit application.
D. All freestanding signs over seven (7) feet in height must submit construction plans prepared by a design
professional licensed in Minnesota that comply with the requirements of the Minnesota State Building Code.
50 -27.2 Enforcement
A. Any sign placed on public property or within a public right -of -way or public easement without authorization
or without a required sign permit can be removed without notice. Such signs will be held by the City for
thirty (30) days. The owner of the sign may reclaim the sign within such period, subject to any fines imposed
by the City. If not reclaimed, the City may destroy the sign following expiration of the thirty (30) day period.
B3If a sign is constructed illegally, either without a required permit or in violation of this section or previous
`� sign regulations, the City may serve notice to the property owner that such sign must be removed or the
violation corrected within thirty (30) days. If the sign is not removed or the violation corrected within the
thirty (30) day period, the City may remove the sign at the property owner's expense. An extension of this
thirty (30) day period may be granted per Section 50- 37.1.0 (Appeals) of this Chapter, and must be applied
for prior to expiration of the initial thirty (30) day period.
50 -27.3 Design and Construction Standards
All signs constructed, erected, modified or altered must comply with the provisions of this section and the
requirements of the City Code.
A. Prohibited Sign Locations
1. No sign may be erected in a location that violates the Minnesota State Building Code, Minnesota State
Fire Code or other regulations.
2. No sign, other than that placed by agencies of government or a sign whose placement is authorized
J
six (6) feet above grade. No sign can be erected that obstructs free and clear vision of any street,
intersection, parking lot ingress or egress, or driveway.
6. No sign may be erected in a manner that _ .. /
obstructs access to fire escapes, any ingress 1
or egress, or standpipes.
7. No sign may be erected on the exterior of a
9 Y i C,gE K S' General
measurement
building to cover any windows or doors. 1 of sign area
±r` V
B. Sign Dimension Measurement Methodology _ —
1. General Measurement of Sign Area
Sign area is measured as follows: (See Figure � .� General
measurement
50- 27 -3.A: Sign Area Measurement) of sign area
la likau (a) For signs on a background, the entire area t "
of the framework or background of the v � N ��r, elf /��
sign is calculated as sign area, including
1
any material or color forming the sign face /
or background used to differentiate the `i
sign from the structure against which it \_.. J
is placed. Sign area does not include any
supports or bracing, unless such framework L _
or bracing is part of the message or sign _
A. . EH ES�S I Sign area for
face. — individual letters
r T ' on structures
(b) For signs consisting of freestanding letters �— t4.1111\1/1
I -- -
or logos, the sign area is calculated as the
total area of each square, circle, rectangle —
or triangle, or combination thereof, that
encompasses each individual letter or
logo. Sign area does not include any
supporting framework or bracing, unless Sign area for
such framework or bracing is part of the individual letters
message or sign face. BUSINESS on windows
(c) Window signs printed on a transparent film NAME
and affixed to the interior or exterior of a
windowpane are calculated as individual 1 i
letters or logos, provided that the portion —��`�" --- - j f
of the transparent film around the __ .I L I_ -,_- C
perimeter of the individual letters or logos
maintains one - hundred percent (100%)
transparency of the window. Transparency Side D ;: ide C
is defined as both the ability to view into - T , ,� \ ,
the interior of the establishment from the ,-.,.''„
outside and to view the outside from the
interior of the establishment through the .... A / fr. Side B
same area.
k
(d) The sign area of a three - dimensional, Y!
free form or sculptural (non planar) \ . '.,: )
t
sign is calculated as fifty percent (50 %)
of the sum of the area of the four (4)
vertical sides of the smallest cube that will
encompass the sign.
(e) If a sign has two (2) or more faces, the Figure 50- 27 -3.A: Sign Area Measurement
2 150 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
area of all faces is included in determining the area of the
sign, unless the two (2) sign faces are placed back to back (a)
and are no more than two (2) feet apart. In such case, the >,
sign area is calculated as the area of one (1) face. If the two
(2) faces are unequal in area, the area of the larger face is
used to calculate sign area.
(f) Necessary supports or uprights on which the sign is erected
are not included in the sign area computation.
2. General Measurement of Sign Height (b)
(a) Measurement of Pole Sign Height
1.�„d
Pole sign height is measured from the grade to the uppermost •
` A
point of the sign. Grade is established by the elevation of the .
back of curb or if no curb exists, from the edge of pavement
at the center of the abutting street frontage where the sign
will be erected. Figure 50- 27 -3.B: Sign Height Measurement
(b) Measurement of Monument Sign Height
Monument sign height is measured from the existing lowest point of the ground where the
monument sign is to be installed to the uppermost point of a sign.
C. Construction Standards
1. Supports and braces must be designed as an integral part of the overall sign design and hidden from
public view to the extent technically feasible.
2. All signs attached to a building must be installed and maintained so that wall penetrations are
watertight and the structure does not exceed allowable stresses of supporting materials.
3. All signs must be designed and constructed in accordance with Minnesota State Building and Fire
Codes. Marquee structures must be approved by the City Engineer and Building Safety Department.
4. Glass forming any part of a sign must be safety glass.
5. All letters, figures, characters or representations in cut -out or irregular form, maintained in
conjunction with, attached to or superimposed upon any sign must be safely and securely built into or
attached to the sign structure.
6. Audio components are prohibited on any sign, with the exception of menuboards.
7. Any form of pyrotechnics is prohibited.
D. Electrical Wiring
1. All electrical fixtures, devices, circuits, conduits, raceways or apparatus used to illuminate, move or
project any sign must be installed and maintained in accordance with Minnesota State Building Code,
including the National Electrical Code. Electrical permits are required for sign installation in accordance
with the Minnesota State Building Code.
2. Conduits and other components of a sign illumination system must be designed as an integral part of
the overall sign structure and hidden from public view to the extent technically feasible.
E. Permit Identification
Every sign must include an identification of the permit number and name of sign installer either painted
on the sign or by the application of a metallic sticker. The information must be visible from the ground
with the exception of signs mounted seven (7) or more feet above grade. Such information does not
count toward the limitation on the items of information described in this section.
F. Limitations on Items of Information
1. All signs must limit the number of items of information on any single sign face to no more than six (6)
items to prevent traffic hazards for passing motorists and to minimize sign clutter.
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 3
2. Each piece of information on a sign is defined as an item of information. For example, each of the
following would be defined as one (1) item of information: a telephone number, the name of the
business (including multi- word), or logo. If the sign advertises products or services, each product or
service (including multi -word) would be one (1) item of information.
3. The following are not counted as an item of information:
(a) Street number address (number only)
(b) A time and temperature component
4. The message area of a changeable message sign or electronic message sign, where information is
changed manually or by computer, shall count as three (3) items of information.
5. All items of information must relate to goods and /or services sold or offered on the premises, with the
exception of non - commercial messages.
6. A sign for a multi- tenant commercial development used to identify the tenants located within the
development is limited to one (1) item of information per tenant within the development and therefore
may exceed six (6) items, in addition to the name and address of
the development.
7. Building directory signs and menuboards are exempt from the items
of information limitation.
G. Required Landscape
All freestanding signs must be landscaped at the base of the sign in
accordance with the following:
1. Freestanding signs must be landscaped with small shrubs a
minimum of eighteen (18) inches in height at planting, spaced
appropriately based on mature height and spread to provide 2'
continuous screening of sign base once shrubs have reached
maturity. The remainder of the landscape area must be planted with
perennials, turf or other live groundcover. z 18"
2. Landscape must extend a minimum of two (2) feet from the
sign base on all sides. All landscape must be maintained in good
condition, and free and clear of rubbish and weeds. Landscape
around the base of a sign is included in the total amount of
landscape required on a site, if applicable.
3. There is no requirement regarding the mature height of landscape, � y
though landscape must be tailored to the scale of the sign. �` 3 .a
Landscape may be trimmed and maintained along the sign base to ,'
maintain visibility of the sign face. � jC ; # 18"
4. When a monument sign is designed as a single structure where the
pediment is constructed of similar or complimentary materials as the n,
sign, and no structural elements that are not related to such overall
design of the sign are visible, no landscape is required.
H. Required Maintenance structural
Elements not
1. All signs must be maintained in a safe, neat and orderly condition , part of sign
and appearance, and must be repainted or otherwise maintained by ` {' j design
the property owner to prevent corrosion or deterioration caused by f'8
the weather, age or any other condition. if /
2. All signs must be maintained to prevent any kind of safety hazard,
including faulty sign structures, a fire hazard or an electrical shock hazard.
3. All unused sign hardware or wiring that is visible from the right -of -way must be removed.
4. If a sign is maintained in an unsafe or insecure condition, the City will give written notice to the
4 150 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
property owner. If property owner fails to remove or alter the structure to comply with the standards
of this section, the sign may be removed by City at the expense of the property owner. The City may
remove any sign that is an immediate peril to persons or property summarily and without notice.
I. Non - Commercial Messages
A non - commercial message may be substituted for a commercial message on any sign permitted by this
section.
J. Architectural Signs
All architectural signs on a structure announcing the original or historic name of the building, year of
construction, or insignias must be maintained, and cannot be removed, altered, or covered. Such signs
are not calculated as part of any sign area or maximum number of signs permitted by this section.
50 -27.4 Illumination Standards
The following illumination standards apply to on- premises signs. Illumination of billboards (off - premises) are
regulated separately in Section 50 -27.7. Additional illumination requirements for electronic message signs are
found in Section 50 -27.7.
A. Any sign illumination, including gooseneck reflectors, external illumination and internal illumination, must
be designed, located, shielded and directed to prevent the casting of glare or direct light upon roadways and
surrounding properties, or the distraction of motor vehicle operators or pedestrians in the public right -of-
way.
B. The sign face of internally illuminated signs must function as a filter to diffuse illumination. The sign face
must cover all internal illumination components so that no exposed bulbs are visible.
C. All external illumination of a sign must concentrate the illumination upon the printed area of the sign face.
D. No sign illumination may exceed one (1) footcandle of illumination at the property line.
E. The use of neon lighting as a sign material or sign accent is permitted for signs within the mixed -use, form -
based and special purpose districts, with the exception of the MU -N and MU -B Districts where it is prohibited.
Neon lighting is subject to the following:
1. When lit, neon lighting must be continuously illuminated. Flashing neon is prohibited.
2. Neon lighting cannot be combined with any reflective materials (e.g., mirrors, polished metal, highly -
glazed tiles, or other similar materials) that would cause glare and increase the spread of light.
3. Neon lighting to outline doors and windows is prohibited.
F. The use of LED lighting as a sign accent is permitted, subject to the following:
1. LED lighting as an accent is only permitted for non - residential uses in the mixed -use, form -based and
special purpose districts where electronic message center signs are permitted. LED accent lighting is
prohibited in any residential district.
2. LED lighting as an accent must comply with all illumination requirements of an electronic message
center sign.
3. The addition of LED lighting as an accent to an existing sign requires a zoning permit.
4. When lit, LED lighting must be continuously illuminated. Flashing LED is prohibited.
5. LED lighting cannot be combined with any reflective materials (e.g., mirrors, polished metal, highly -
glazed tiles, or other similar materials) that would cause glare and increase the spread of light.
6. LED lighting to outline doors and windows is prohibited.
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS ( 5
50 -27.5 Prohibited Signs
The following signs are prohibited:
A. Balloon and air- infused /air - inflated signs.
B. Electronic display screens.
C. Flashing or animated signs.
D. Illegally- affixed signs.
E. Moving signs, including signs moved by wind or mechanical or electrical components. No sign or part of any
sign shall move or give the illusion of movement in any manner. Clocks and barber poles are exempt from this
provision.
F. Portable signs. Portable signs include both signs mounted on a wheeled structure and those mounted on a
stationary structure that can be moved and is not permanently installed on a site.
G. Roof signs.
H. Snipe signs.
I. Strobe lights, moving or fixed spotlights, and floodlights.
J. Temporary off - premises signs.
K. Traffic hazard signs. Any sign that constitutes a traffic hazard is prohibited, including signs that:
1. Interfere with, obstruct the view of, or may be confused with any authorized traffic sign, signal or device
because of its position, shape or color, including signs illuminated in red, green or amber color to resemble
a traffic signal.
2. Make use of the words STOP, LOOK, DETOUR, DANGER , CAUTION, WARNING or any other word, phrase,
symbol or character in a manner that misleads, interferes with, or confuses traffic.
L. Vehicle signs. Signs placed or painted on parked vehicles where the primary purpose is to advertise a product
or service, or to direct the public to a business or activity located on or off the premises, are prohibited. Signs
painted on vehicles, trucks or buses, which are being operated and stored in the normal course of business, such
as signs located on delivery trucks, promotional vehicles, moving vans and rental trucks, are permitted, provided
that the primary purpose of such vehicles is not the display of signs, and that they are parked or stored in areas
related to their use as vehicles. Vehicle for -sale signs are exempt from this provision.
50 -27.6 Signs and Activities Exempt from Permit Requirements
A. Alteration and Maintenance Operations
The following activities are exempt from a zoning permit:
1. Painting, repainting, cleaning, changing permitted items of information and /or other normal maintenance
and repair of a sign, not involving structural alterations or changes in the electrical components of the sign.
Repairs to existing permitted illumination components are also exempt from sign permit requirements.
2. Changing of the message of an existing changeable message sign or electronic message sign.
3. Changing the sign face within an existing legal sign structure, provided no alterations are made to the sign
structure and the sign area, sign height or any other dimension of the sign.
B. Illumination
No exempt sign may be illuminated, except for the following:
1. Uplighting of official federal, state, county or city flags.
2. Lighting of official federal, state, county or city government signs as needed by the government body.
6 1 50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
C. Exempt Permanent Signs
This section describes the types of permanent signs that are allowed without a zoning permit. All exempt
signs must comply with all the regulations of this section. Exempt permanent signs are subject to the
regulations of Table 50 -27 -1: Exempt Permanent Sign Regulations.
TABLE 50 -27 -1: EXEMPT PERMANENT SIGN REGULATIONS
I'ER\IITTED MAXIMUM HEIGHT 'k_ I BACK OR
[CAN DISTRIC' I' PERMIIITED MAXIMUM NUMBER PER
SIGN TYPE SIZE (FREESTANDING LOCATION LOT
OR 1'\! SIGNS) (FREESTANDING;
RC, RR -1, RR-
Agricultural All agricultural Freestanding 2: 20sf 20' from front lot 1 per street
Identification uses or wall 6' line & 10' from frontage
Sign All other any other lot line
districts: 6sf
Building All multi- Freestanding Within 10' of 1 per building
Directory Sign family &non or wall 6sf building entry entry
residential uses
1 per access
point + 1 per
intersection of
Directional Sign All parking lots from any lot driveways or
- Parking Lot & structures Freestanding 6sf 5' line service entries
within a site +
1 per drive -
through lane
Flags — Federal, All districts & Flagpole limited to 5' from any lot
State or Local uses Freestanding No Limit maximum height of line No limit
zoning district
Flagpole limited to
Flags — All non- Freestanding 16sf maximum height of 5' from any lot 1 per lot
Commercial residential uses zoning district line
Government Sign All districts & Freestanding
(Federal, State, uses or wall No Limit No Limit No Limit No Limit
County or City)
Wall,
All residential Window, or
freestanding
Home dwelling uses including 4sf 4' 5' from any lot 1 per lot
Occupation Sign & permitted line
accessory uses mounting
on private
lightposts
Memorial Plaque All districts & Freestanding 6sf 5' 5' from any lot 1 per lot
uses or wall line
Nameplate All districts & Wall 4sf (Not Applicable) (Not Applicable) 1 per lot
uses
Parking Lot All parking lots Freestanding lOsf 6' 0' from any lot No Limit
Information Sign & structures or wall line
Property All multi - family
Identification residential uses Wall 4sf (Not Applicable) (Not Applicable) 1 per lot
Sign
•
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 1
TABLE 50 -27 -1: EXEMPT PERMANENT SIGN REGULATIONS (CONTINUED)
RLQI•iRLD
PERMITTED SIA.NISIUMI HEIGHT SETBACK OR NUMBER PER
PERMITTED M %
AXI \It" '
YGN DISTRICT (FREESTANDING LOCATION
OR USE SIGN TYPE SIZE SIGNS) LOT
(FREESTANDING;
SIGNS)
The following
uses:
All educational
facilities;
Public Cemetery or Freestanding No Limit No Limit No Limit No Limit
Information Sign mausoleum; or wall
Museum, library
or art gallery;
Park, playground
or forest reserve
20% of
Must be sign area of
Time & integrated freestanding
Temperature All non- into primary or wall (Not Applicable) (Not Applicable) 1 per lot
Sign (Electronic) residential uses freestanding sign, or if
or wall sign standalone
sign, 6sf
Temporary &
permanent
Permanent All non- signs (Not
Window Sign residential uses Window (combined) are (Not applicable) (Not applicable) applicable)
g limited to 30%
coverage of
window
D. Exempt Temporary Signs
This section describes the types of temporary signs that are allowed without a zoning permit. All exempt
signs must comply with all the regulations of this section.
1. Exempt temporary signs are subject to the display periods in Table 50 -27 -2: Permitted Display Period.
TABLE 50 - 27 - 2: PERMITTED DISPLAY PERIOD
SIGN PERMITTED DISPLAY PERIOD
When related to a time - specific event: Combined display period of 14 days prior to the event,
Attention - Getting Device the time period of the event and 2 days following the event
When not related to a time - specific event: 10 days
Limited to no more than 4 display periods in a year, with a minimum of 30 days between displays
When related to a time - specific event: Combined display period of 14 days prior to the event,
Banner (General) the time period of the event and 2 days following the event
When not related to a time - specific event: 30 days
Limited to no more than 4 display periods in a year, with a minimum of 30 days between displays
Community Event Sign Limited to no more than 4 display periods in a year for a total aggregate display time of 20 days
per year
Construction Sign Erected only after approval of a building permit and must be removed within 7 days of issuance
of an occupancy permit or completion of construction, whichever occurs first
General: No display period limitation
Non - Commercial Message Election: Signs of any size related to an election or referendum may be posted in any number
Sign from 46 days before the state primary in a state general election year until 10 days following the
state general election
All real estate signs may only be erected on the specific property offered for sale or lease or the
property holding an open house
Real Estate Sign Real estate for sale /lease signs: Posted for the duration the property is offered for sale or lease,
and must be removed within 7 days of closing or lease
Real estate open house signs: Only during the day of the open house and must be removed
within 2 hours of the end of the event
Temporary Window Sign No display period limitation
8 50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
2. Exempt temporary signs are subject to the regulations of Table 50 -27 -3: Exempt Temporary Sign
Regulations.
TABLE 50 -27 -3: EXEMPT TEMPORARY SIGN REGULATIONS
MAXIMUM
PERMITTED ED PERMITTED MAXIMUM HEIGHT SETBACK OR NUMBER PER
DISTRICT LOCATION
,� SIGN TYPE SIZE (FREESTANDING (FREESTANDING
SIGNS) SIGNS)
Attention - Getting Non - residential 10' from any lot
Device uses in MU -C Freestanding lOsf line 1 per lot
Non - residential Wall or
Banner (General) uses retaining wall 32sf (Not applicable) (Not applicable) 1 per lot
Community Event All districts & uses Freestanding lOsf 6' 10' from any lot 1 per lot
Sign or wall line
Construction Sign All districts & uses Freestanding 50sf 6' 10' from any lot 505f total per
or wall line street frontage
Non - Commercial Freestanding,
Message Sign All districts & uses wall or No limit No limit No limit No limit
retaining wall
Residential
Districts:
Real Estate Sign All districts & uses Freestanding 4sf 5 , 10' from any lot 1 per street
or wall All Other line frontage
Districts:
12sf
Temporary
permanent
Temporary All non - residential signs (Not
Window Sign uses Window (combined) (Not applicable) (Not applicable)
are limited
applicable)
to 30%
coverage of
window
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 9
50 -27.7 Sign Types — Permit Required
A. General Regulations
The following types of signs require a zoning permit before they can be erected on a site. Table 50 -27-
4: Sign Types - Permit Required: District and Use Permissions describes where these types of signs are
permitted.
TABLE 50 -27 -4: SIGN TYPES - PERMIT REQUIRED: DISTRICT AND USE PERMISSIONS
KEY:
1 : Residential Uses
IA : Mufti-Family Dwelling Only
2 : Public, Institutional and Civic Uses
3 : Commercial Uses
4 : Industrial Uses NOTE: Accessory uses are subject to the home occupation sign standards
U ru a z U — m o+ lg
A -Frame Sign 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2
Awning IA IA IA IA IA IA IA IA lA IA lA IA IA 1A 1A IA lA IA IA 1A 1A IA
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Banner - 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Exhibition
Billboard 1 3 3 3
4 4 4
Canopy 1A IA IA IA IA 1A lA IA 1A lA IA 1A 1A IA IA IA IA IA IA IA 1A lA
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Electronic 2 2 2 2 2
Message 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 2 2 2
Sign 2 4 4 4 4 4
Freestanding 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Signs — Pole 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 2 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Freestanding 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Signs — 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Monument 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Marquee 3 3 3 3 3 3
Menuboard 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Projecting 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Sign 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Scoreboard 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Wall Sign 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Billboards are permitted on any lot within the noted districts, whether developed or undeveloped, unless such lot is developed
for a one - family or two - family dwelling.
2 Filling station uses in any district are permitted to display fuel prices by an electronic message component, and are subject to
the restrictions of that section.
3 Menuboards are permitted only for a drive- through use. In the case of existing nonconformities within districts that contain
drive - through facilities, menuboards are permitted for the drive - through use until such time as the structure is demolished.
10 50-27. SIGN REGULATIONS
y -"
B. A -Frame Sign 't 'j
A -frame signs are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4, subject to •t'ef
the following regulations. ' '`
1. A -frame signs are limited to six (6) square feet in area per side and
four (4) feet in height.
2. The use of A -frame signs is limited
to business hours only. Signs must ${ I 1=—
be stored indoors at all other times. - -=--
A -frame signs must not be used - - -- -- - ----- - - - -- --- - - - - -- - --
outdoors when high winds, heavy rain
or heavy snow conditions are present. r
A -frame signs may be removed during
City snow removal operations and -
the City is not liable for any damage I •
to signs caused by snow removal
operations. :
"--- 8' min. *.
3. One (1) A -frame sign is permitted per
business, per street frontage of that j
business. A minimum eight (8) foot 5' min.
separation is required between all 1
A -frame signs.
4. An A -frame sign must be placed on
the property where the business is
located and within ten (10) feet of 111111111116
the primary entrance of the business
or on the right -of -way in front of " '' ' ilay�� tv'IJ�S
.
property. A -frame signs must provide
an unobstructed sidewalk width of i,
at least five (5) feet for pedestrian _ Limited to 6
square feet in
passage and must not interfere with ""`` 4' max. ®�: area per side
pedestrian traffic or violate standards hei ht
of accessibility as required by the 9 .6
ADA or other accessibility codes. 's•
l' 5. he permit applicant must provide �= .•
and maintain in force a certificate of --------------4 insurance, in a form approved by the
City, that evidences that the applicant
has in force insurance in the minimum
amounts required by the City for
bodily injuries or property damage in any one (1) year protecting such person or organization and the
City against liability for injuries or damages resulting from the placement of such objects or materials
in the public right -of -way.
C . Awning
s
-paLil justinpaul
Awnings without printing, with the exception of a street address I ,,
number (number only), are considered an architectural feature and -
are not regulated by this section. This section regulates awning
signs, which are used to identify a use by name or logo, the goods or
services offered on -site, and similar sign information. Awning signs ,„„
are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4, subject to the following # �
regulations a S,:�xy $ .. :a. <:
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 111
--' 1 '-i - - ' - ,L - : - • -: 1- -:__-_-: .-_____Htir'' -41'; J
1. Awning signs must maintain a minimum r-
vertical clearance of seven feet six
inches (7' 6 "). W„ /
2. Awning signs must be located a .. �„ �s
eighteen (18) inches from i. / -§s
minimum of ei 4.;
9 ( ) Printing limited to 30%
the back of curb. of awning surface f , a
area
3. Awning signs must comply with .
Minnesota State Building and Fire Codes, 7'6' min. clearance
including provisions for encroachment .. '
into the public right-of-way, structural - -.A--
requirements, sprinkler protections and '18
similar regulations. ` ��
4. Awning signs must be made of a
durable, weather- resistant material like
canvas, canvas -like material, nylon,
vinyl coated fabric or metal. " $' P -"'
5. Printing on any awning sign is limited to / „-
thirty percent (30 %) of the surface area. r , i, 71 ., ,,,
6. Awning signs are permitted lettering T z ?rte y . , --
attached to and located above the top of i � � __
` - ----
n , x- -
a solid awning to a maximum height of 4 1� ~a"
twenty -four (24) inches. ' 7 E
;
r '
ii _1 i li t `,
7. Awning signs may illuminate the printed 1 Ill'
area of the awning with gooseneck or • 4� li � �. ; Le tterin g attached to and located
similar external illumination. Back -lit + 1" above awning permitted toa
awnings are prohibited. \ "4 height r � a;t `+ , r
8. Under - awning signs are permitted fii L- I
subject to the following: - _�
(a) Under - awning signs must be am
attached to the underside of an ir
awning. Under - awning signs must
not project beyond the awning.
(b) Under - awning signs must maintain a P' �,„-r a
t
g "A minimum vertical clearance of seven �r
(7) feet. w r �_T- -�
(c) A maximum of one (1) under - awning . i
sign is permitted per business _ 1 ,
: .� ..w�
establishment with frontage on the , y � - --� ll'i � �
street where the awning is mounted. ' € ' I + Maximum of 6 • l ; square feet for
" 1 i it I under awning signs ° „,"
(d) Each under awning sign is limited to i i I 7- _
a maximum of six (6) square feet. t- v ',' 1 I■ I 6Y l ,i t
:i l 't. i' . '''' i 6
(e) Under awning signs must be ,- 7 mn clearance i {i t °
securely fixed to the awning with i n.: I I t �
metal supports. - - ,
(f) Under - awning signs must be made
of wood, metal or plastic.' -
12 150 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
Maximum banner
_ size of 60 square feet
D. Banner - Exhibition -
Exhibition banners are permitted for / 1 N.
events and exhibitions as indicated in : _ �, a \a
Table 50 -27 -4, subject to the following 41,
regulations.
1. Each use is permitted up to six (6) Irk ; �= - 1 -41 , �...., ``.
exhibition banners during one display
period. The display period is defined r "
as the combined period of thirty
(30) days prior to the opening of the i `
exhibit, the run of the exhibit, and
fourteen (14) days following the close of the exhibit.
2. Exhibition banners must be made of a durable, weather - resistant material like canvas, nylon or vinyl -
coated fabric.
3. Each exhibition banner is limited to a maximum sign area of sixty (60) square feet.
4. Exhibition banners must be securely and tautly attached to the wall of the structure and no exhibition
banner may be located higher than the roofline.
E. Billboard
1. Billboards are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4 subject to the :vEVEiNC N .:•
following regulations. However, billboards are only permitted in the MU -B ouR INTERNET 4
SPEEDS I"lGAI s _;,
and I -G Districts with the use of an exception credit (Section 50- 38.7). enyourChildn-
Billboards are also further restricted by the requirements of Minnesota 19 1 h r� er more than vou
State Statute Section 173.08, Subdivision 2, as amended from time to ` ° time.
2. The maximum sign area for a billboard is seven - hundred (700) square
feet.
• 3. Billboards adjacent to on -grade roadways are limited to a maximum
height of twenty -five (25) feet. Billboards adjacent to grade separated/
elevated roadways are permitted to
measure the twenty -five (25) foot
height from the roadbed crown to the
tallest projection of the structure. This '
measurement is taken at a perpendicular
angle between the grade separated/
elevated roadway and the sign location.
25' max. height
4. Billboards may only be mounted as
freestanding pole signs. However, when
an exception credit is used, billboards
may be wall- mounted and are limited o -
to the wall sign area allowed for that F -,,
��' Max. area of
district. ;
700 square feet
5. Billboards are required to be spaced five—
hundred (500) feet apart, subject to the
following: I
25 max. height
(a) Billboards located along Interstate -- ---- - - - - -- �' F
Highway No. 35 and Interstate
Highway No. 535 must be spaced
eight hundred (800) feet apart, unless erected under an exception credit in which case only the five -
hundred (500) foot spacing is required.
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 13
(b) Spacing is measured along the Billboards must be
nearest edge of the right -of -way spaced a minimum of
pavement to which the billboard 500' apart = / /
is displayed and between points
directly opposite the center of the
billboard.
(c) Spacing requirements apply only to
billboards located on the same side
of the same highway.
(d) Multi -faced or back -to -back ,
j�
billboards, up to a maximum of a
five (5) foot separation between
sign faces, are considered one (1)
billboard.
6. Electronic billboards are permitted only in the MU -C, MU -B, and I -G Districts. Electronic billboards are
subject to the following regulations:
(a) An electronic billboard may only be erected if one (1) of the following criteria is met:
(i) The electronic billboard is constructed using exception credits. The number of exception credits,
in square footage, must equal three (3) times the square footage of the electronic billboard to be
constructed.
(ii) Nonconforming billboards of a total square footage are removed in an amount equal to three (3)
times the square footage of the electronic billboard to be constructed.
(b) Each message displayed on an electronic billboard must be static or depicted for a minimum of eight
(8) seconds. Any scrolling, flashing or movement of the message is prohibited.
(c) The maximum brightness of an electronic billboard is limited to five - thousand (5,000) nits or four -
hundred sixty -four (464) candelas per square foot during daylight hours, and five- hundred (500)
nits or forty -six (46) candelas per square foot between dusk to dawn. The billboard must have
an automatic dimmer control that produces a distinct illumination change from a higher allowed
illumination level to a lower allowed level for the time period between one -half hour before sunset
and one -half hour after sunrise.
E Canopy
Canopies without printing, with the exception of a street address alk
number (number only), are considered an architectural feature and �tQFt3�,
are not regulated by this section. This section regulates canopy
• signs, which are used to identify a use by name or logo, the goods or j 0\ \
services offered on -site, and similar sign information. Canopy signs 1
are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4 subject to the following
regulations.
1. Canopy signs must maintain a minimum vertical clearance of seven feet a
six inches (7' 6 ").
2. Canopy signs must be located at least eighteen (18) inches from the back of curb. Support posts must
maintain a minimum separation of five (5) feet between posts and between the posts and any building
wall. No obstructions are permitted within this area.
3. Canopy signs must comply with Minnesota State Building and Fire Codes, including provisions for
encroachment into the public right -of -way, structural requirements, sprinkler protections and similar
regulations.
4. Canopy signs must be made of a durable, weather - resistant material like canvas, canvas -like material,
nylon, vinyl- coated fabric or metal.
14 150 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
5. Printing on any canopy sign is limited
to thirty percent (30 0 /o) of the surface t
area. ' 4 ".t,L
6. Canopies may include underside, i
external illumination. � f ' :: ' —
7. Under canopy signs are permitted 1
subject to the following: 1, 7'6" min.
clearance
(a) Under - canopy signs must be `
attached to the underside of a I
999- -- 5' min.
canopy. Under - canopy signs must _ j
..+ between posts. &
not project beyond the canopy. 18 min. butwegn posts &
P l Y PY• _ ,_ building wall
(b) Under - awning signs must maintain `�
a minimum vertical clearance of , t ii-}_ �—
seven (7) feet. f� t I
(c) A maximum of one (1) under -
canopy sign is permitted.
(d) Each under - canopy sign is limited I-7
' ii. \
to a maximum of six (6) square p
feet. 1 '
(e) Under - canopy signs must be g
securely fixed to the awning with
metal supports. t ' \, . ' '
limited to30'.
;i! • ! of • n py surface
(f) Under - awning canopy must be I ar.
made of wood, metal or plastic. t I, '
..).1- ' 1 _____1/0
G. Electronic Message Sign . - - ...-
Electronic message signs are permitted -----/ - q ,
tf
as indicated in Table 50-27-4 subject j /ATK� c
to the following regulations. However, t /hi ce
all filling stations in any district are
permitted to display fuel prices by an
a component. Such
Maximum t 6
electronic messa
9 P '', 1` i square feet for
component must only display numerical 1 1 under - canopy signs
fuel prices and must be static. t_
\
1. Only one (1) electronic message sign \. I k 7' min, clearance
per lot is permitted. _ ',',44,'y t 11I
2. Each message or image displayed ' 1
on an electronic message sign must _ T --- I
be static or depicted for a minimum • t '• _
of eight (8) seconds. Any scrolling,
flashing or movement of the message I
is prohibited.
3. The maximum brightness of an
electronic message sign is limited to five- thousand (5,000) nits or four - hundred sixty -four (464)
candelas per square foot during daylight hours, and five- hundred (500) nits or forty -six (46) candelas
per square foot between dusk to dawn. The sign must have an automatic dimmer control that
produces a distinct illumination change from a higher allowed illumination level to a lower allowed
level for the time period between one -half hour before sunset and one -half hour after sunrise.
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 115
4. Electronic message signs are permitted as part of a freestanding sign, wall sign or marquee and, in
addition, are subject to the requirements for those sign types.
5. Electronic message signs must be integrated into the larger sign structure and must include the name
of the use as a non - electronic component as part of the sign structure. Electronic message signs are
limited to a maximum of sixty -five percent (65 %) of the sign area of a freestanding or wall sign.
6. Electronic message signs cannot display any off - premises commercial advertising.
7. Electronic display screens are prohibited.
H. Freestanding Signs — Pole and Monument
Freestanding signs are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4, subject ug 'k
to the following regulations.
1. Freestanding sign maximum height and sign areas are as indicated in u s
Table 50 -27 -5.
2. Only one (1) freestanding sign, either pole or monument, is
permitted per street frontage of a lot. For each additional one -
hundred (100) feet of street frontage, above an initial one - hundred 1
(100) feet of frontage, an additional freestanding sign, either pole or
monument, is permitted.
3. All freestanding signs over seven (7)
feet in height must submit construction
plans prepared by a design professional
Sign area determined
licensed in Minnesota that comply with the by table,.
requirements of the Minnesota State Building _
Code.
4. No part of a freestanding sign may project r i See Table for
into, over or otherwise encroach on a public "''" '►- r � .� Maximum Heights
right-of -way. a -,—
_ ��`
( 8'min.
5. A freestanding pole sign must maintain a clearance
minimum vertical clearance of eight (8) j
feet. No temporary signs may be attached
to the pole of a freestanding pole sign or the
pole may not be wrapped in any decorative
that is not an integral part of the
pole structure.
6. Freestanding monument signs may be
internally or externally illuminated. If
externally illuminated, all light must be j -
directed onto the sign face. Freestanding t 6.1_0.
pole signs may only be internally
illuminated. _
c'
See table for
- - / maximum heights
8" max.
I
16 50-27. SIGN REGULATIONS
TABLE 50 -27 -5: FREESTANDING SIGN REGULATIONS
ui, ■ 111 . iv u L v( ):..it AID,: i
Maximum Sign Area Maximum Sign Height Maximum Sign Area Maximum Sign Height
R -C 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
RR -1 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
RR -2 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
R -1 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
R -2 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
R -P 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
MU -N 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
MU -C 60sf 25' 50sf 8'
MU -I 60sf 25' 50sf 8'
MU -B Prohibited Prohibited 50sf 8'
MU -W 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -1 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -2 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -3 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -4 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -5 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -6 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -7 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
F -8 42sf 15' 32sf 6'
F -9 60sf 25' SOsf 8'
I -G 60sf 25' SOsf 8'
u
I -W 60sf 25' SOsf 8'
P -1 42sf 17' 32sf 6'
I. Marquee 1 A
µ
Marquees are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4, subject to the fa z $ aT
following regulations. •
1. Marquees must be supported solely by the building to which they are
attached. No exterior columns or posts are permitted as supports. # • •
2. No marquee may be erected on any building or other structure of .�
wood frame construction. :
3. The roof of a marquee may not be
used for any purpose other than to
1 ' ' - ' t l .
form and constitute a roof and must
be constructed of noncombustible '(
material. I�,
4. Water from the roofs of a marquee ` '''--..1
\ t 1 N� e.
�1.
may not drain, drip or Flow onto the � 1�. _ - _
surface of a public sidewalk. Sufficient + - �Y j
downspouts, drains and gutters must \,.
■
be installed as part of each marquee / j
to prevent water from the roof of
the marquee from flowing onto the
surface of a public sidewalk. --__ I
5. Marquees must be erected over a �` ; 174t- '�' = �
\ 18' min. \,)
\ 50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 1
Lettenng attached to
and located above i .1441 7
the roof of a marquee
is permitted to a / i
ot building entrance and are limited to ma height } or -Q l L
the width of the building entrance. An irismis 11 010 " -- I'
additional five (5) feet on each side ()NOMGAO'A
of the entrance doors covered by the
marquee is permitted.
r ._._.
Marquees must
6. All marquees must maintain a be erectedovera
minimum vertical clearance of eight 1 i building entrance,
(8) feet and the roof of the marquee -. - _ and are limited to
structure must be erected below the the width of the
J, building entrance.
second Floor window sill. Marquees . - An additional 5' on
may encroach up to eighteen (18) each side of the
nches from the back of curb. ar, il
:! entrance doors �s
permitted.
7. Marquees are permitted lettering
attached to and located above the roof
of a marquee to a maximum height of twenty -four (24) inches.
8. Marquees may be internally illuminated. External Illumination is prohibited.
J. Menuboard i.
Drive - through establishments are permitted one (1) menuboard sign -;-
per drive - through lane, constructed as freestanding pole or monument
sign, no more than forty (40) square feet in sign area, no more than ki i 1 -..., 4.r
IL
seven (7) feet in height and no less than fifteen (15) feet from any 4
lot line. Menuboards may be internally or externally illuminated. For r'
menuboards, the audio component is limited to communication between .ii it it
customer and service.
�_ '3tga:'EEL
1 rCoSP
40 square foot _
maximum area 7' Maximum Height
sg
s
irma —
j
75-. M/nlmum Dista ho
rn /Of tine
18 150 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
' ' r V-
K. Projecting Sign
Projecting signs are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4, subject to
the following regulations. {
1. Projecting sign maximum area is as indicated in Table 50 -27 -6.
2. One (1) projecting sign is permitted gg
per establishment with frontage on ,' ' !
a street. For a corner lot, one (1) ;% � A tl i
projecting sign is permitted for each i � a i i\ ' _. -
street frontage. Projecting signs / ,,II �, i1 .� `J \ '—
must be above or adjacent to the E = i1 , 11 '
,,°"� 6' Maximum
building entrance or if a corner lot, �i� Projection •
the corner of the building. ! I'�' I 1 i i -'.
3. Projecting signs may not project t o Y � I 1 =- ---- --
more than six (6) feet from the face 4 11 i
T ;;, 8' Minimum I
of the building to which they are _ Vertical Clearance i
attached, including the area between .,...4./T40.0! � iII �,
._-
the sign and the face of the building. � :f '{ il i
i.
4. Projecting signs must maintain a �,- ,,,� :.., ,
minimum vertical clearance of eight __ �� h � , ;
(8) feet. No projecting r
8 r i'
p j 9 si 9 n affixed I, �i li 1 I I ��
to a building may project higher than
the building height, including the TABLE 50 -27 -6: PROJECTING SIGN
sign support structure. REGULATIONS
5. Projecting signs, including frames, braces, and supports, DISI1UCF - ',I AREA
must be designed by a licensed structural engineer or R - Prohibited
manufacturer. No projecting sign may be secured with wire, RR - Prohibited
chains, strips of wood or nails nor may any projecting sign
be hung or secured to any other sign. Any movable part of a RR - Prohibited
projecting sign, such as the cover of a service opening, must R - Prohibited
be securely fastened by chains or hinges. R - Prohibited
6. Projecting signs must be constructed of wood, metal, R - Prohibited
durable, weather - resistant material like canvas, canvas -like MU - 36sf
material, nylon or vinyl- coated fabric, or plastic. Projecting MU - 48sf
signs constructed of material must be mounted so that they MU - 48sf
are held taut between support posts.
MU - B 48sf
7. Projecting signs may be internally or externally illuminated. MU - 36sf
If externally illuminated, all lighting must be directed onto
the sign face from above. F - 36sf
F - 2 36sf
8. Maximum projecting sign areas are provided in Table 50 - 27 -
6: Projecting Sign Regulations. F -3 36sf
F -4 36sf
F -5 36sf
F -6 36sf
F -7 36sf
F -8 48sf
F -9 48sf
I -G 48sf
I -W 48sf
P -1 Prohibited
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 119
L. Scoreboard & Outfield Signs
1. Scoreboards and outfield signs are permitted as indicated in Table '' -.•:- I
50 -27 -4, subject to the following regulations. Such signs are further y - .,r
restricted to recreational playing fields only. — -
Ix. MI
2. Scoreboards must be constructed as a freestanding pole sign, no y fr -;a
more than two- hundred and forty (240) square feet in sign area and a 1,, maS ( 5 µf!
twenty -five (25) feet in height.
3. The score - keeping portion of the scoreboard may utilize an electronic i I
message component.
4. If the scoreboard cannot be viewed
from any adjacent right -of -way as
measured along five - hundred (500)
- foot sight lines from the scoreboard, . -- r - r
up to forty percent (40 %) of the sign -= „C
area may be used for off - premises 'd° , - , ,
advertisin If the scoreboard can be �°
9• ry� I f f� ' 1 Maximum area of
viewed from any adjacent right -of- - - iL 240 square feet
way, up to thirty percent (30 %) of 25' Maximum — —
the sign area may be used for off-
Height
premises advertising.
5. There is no limit on the number of
outfield advertising signs so long as
no such signs are visible from an •
adjacent right -of -way. No permit is I
required for outfield advertising signs.
6. Scoreboards and outfield signs that
are part of a sports stadium as a
principal use are considered part of X 11 1 1 :i
the structure and not subject to these �
standards. 40 1sI” (. .I
i it t
� t r� -� a
r Li
,..: 4 -' '41 - -
?� '' ) . l-
" I,' I 40% off - premises
6. CL„-------.----"'": ��` a
20 150 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
M. Wall Sign . CP
Wall signs are permitted as indicated in Table 50 -27 -4, subject to the •. a
following regulations. �^
1. The maximum size of a wall sign is established at two (2) square feet T ZrG��14 $
per linear foot of building facade where the wall sign will be mounted . . . . • • -
or forty (40) square feet, whichever is greater.
•
2. In addition, any structure over seven (7) stories in height is
permitted one (1) additional wall sign per facade to identify the
building, that must be placed within the top twenty (20) feet of the
structure and cannot not cover any
fenestration or architectural features.
The maximum size is established at , y �I 1 ! I
, r,
two (2) square feet per linear foot L= J �. li I '
of building facade, measured at the
i ll be = �� �� '(/ # ,c„ J
F
roof line, where the wall sign �
g {
mounted. IC I C ,,', 1 °.f 1.i _--
3. Wall signs may be internally or
externally illuminated. If externally
illuminated, all light must be directed • Maximum of two I i
onto the sign face from above. i ;. (2) square feet per ! —
linear foot of building r". 8' Minimum 7..r
4. Wall signs must be safely and t il facade where the
sign will be mounted, ' Vertical Clearance
securely attached to the building wall. [J
the wall and must not project more greater. —
than eighteen (18) inches from the , l '
a
building wall. c '- . . 1 - L-- --`"�-
5. If a wall sign projects more than two
(2) inches from the surface, a minimum vertical clearance of eight
(8) feet is required.
ill
6. No wall sign mounted on a structure may project above the roof
of the structure to which it is attached, including the sign support
structure. Wall signs may be mounted on a parapet wall when such
parapet is consistent with the architectural design of the structure
and /or the larger development, and such parapet wall is constructed
of the same primary building materials as the structure, excluding
any accent materials.
7. Wall signs must be constructed of wood, brick, metal or plastic. Wall
signs constructed of material must be mounted so that they are held
taut against the wall.
8. Wall signs must not cover windows, doors or architectural features. However, wall signs are permitted
on architectural appurtenances, such as chimneys or penthouses, which are part of the original
structure.
9. Ghost signs are considered wall signs. Existing ghost signs are exempt from these requirements and
deemed conforming. Ghost signs may be maintained and repainted but no new information or images
may be added to the existing sign. No new wall signs may be painted on structures.
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS 1
by public rights -of -way or by individual parcels not owned by the institution. However, the entire area must
function as a connected campus.
C. As part of the establishment of a Campus Sign Plan, a comprehensive sign plan must be submitted. The
comprehensive sign plan must describe the sign standards for the campus, including all exceptions to the
requirements of this section. A campus sign plan may be more permissive than the standards of this section.
Directional signs within the campus may be described generally by sign area and height, and general
locations.
D. The Planning Commission shall review the application, conduct a public hearing pursuant to Section 50-
37.1.I, with public notice as required by Section 50- 37.1.H, and make a decision to adopt, adopt with
modifications, or deny the application.
E. Alternately, a Campus Sign Plan may be incorporated into the review and approval process of the District
Plan Option of the MU -I District.
50 -27.11 Classic Signs
A. Purpose
Because the City recognizes that certain existing signs do not conform with this Chapter but are
particularly unique and /or have historic value, including signs for products or businesses that are no
longer located on -site, the classic sign designation is established where the City can designate certain
signs as classic signs. Once designated, the classic sign is deemed conforming, and thus is no longer
nonconforming, provided the sign is maintained in good condition and its physical integrity remains
intact. Any sign designated on the national historic register is automatically considered a classic sign
under this section.
B. Eligibility
1. An owner of a sign, or the City may apply for designation of an existing sign as a classic sign. Classic
signs are exempt from area, setback, height, lighting, movement, placement, type, content, and
construction materials requirements of this section.
2. To qualify for designation as a classic sign, the sign must:
(a) Be at least twenty -five (25) years old or an exact replica of an original sign where the combined
age of the duplicate and original sign is at least twenty -five (25) years.
(b) Possess unique physical design characteristics, such as configuration, message, color, texture,
etc.
(c) Be of significance to the City, regardless of the use identified by the sign.
3. A sign designated a classic sign may remain on the premises even if the original use to which the sign
relates is no longer located on the premises. A designated classic sign may also be moved to a new
structure.
C. Application
The application for classic sign status must be made to the Land Use Supervisor, who will schedule a
public hearing. The Planning Commission may approve or deny the application.
D. Maintenance
The owner of a classic sign must ensure that the sign is not structurally dangerous, a fire hazard, an
electrical shock hazard, or any other kind of hazard. Classic signs may be rebuilt if damaged.
E. Designated Classic Signs
The following are deemed to be signs of special significance in the City and are, therefore, designated
classic signs and exempt from the provisions of this Chapter:
NOTE: The City may choose to designate classic signs as part of the adoption of these sign regulations.
50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS ( 23
NONCONFORMING SIGNS
50 -38.6 Legal Nonconforming On- Premises Signs
A. A legal nonconforming sign may remain in use, so long as it remains otherwise lawful, meets the
requirements of this Chapter, and has not been damaged or destroyed as described in Paragraph D below.
The sign face of an existing legal nonconforming sign may be replaced, but the structure cannot be altered.
B. No legal nonconforming sign may be relocated, in whole or in part, to any other location on the same
or other lot, unless the entire sign conforms to all regulations of the zoning district in which the sign is
relocated.
C. No legal nonconforming sign can be altered or enlarged in a way that increases the nonconformity of the
sign. This item in no way precludes normal maintenance and cleaning or changing of the sign face.
D. In the event that any legal nonconforming sign is damaged or destroyed to the extent of more than fifty
percent (50 %) of its value prior to the damage, the sign cannot be restored or repaired unless it conforms to
all applicable regulations for the district.
E. All electronic message signs and electronic billboards that do not conform with the display requirements of
this Chapter, including brightness, message duration and similar performance requirements for the electronic
component, are required to conform to the standards of this Chapter for the electronic component within
ninety (90) days of this date, (date of adoption)
50 -38.7 Legal Nonconforming Off - Premises Signs
Keep current provisions and remove section D.
24 50 -27. SIGN REGULATIONS
DEFINITIONS
SIGN, A- FRAME. A sign ordinarily in the shape of the letter "A," or some variation thereof, that is displayed on
the ground, not permanently attached, and usually two- sided.
SIGN, AGRICULTURAL IDENTIFICATION. A sign describing an agricultural use that includes the name
of the farm and /or the products grown on -site.
SIGN, ANIMATED. A sign that uses movement or change of lighting to depict action or to create a special
effect or scene. ANIMATED SIGNS do not include ELECTRONIC MESSAGE SIGNS.
SIGN, ATTENTION GETTING DEVICE. Flags, pennants, streamers and similar devices or ornamentations
designated for the purpose of attracting attention. Flags of nations, states, and cities, or fraternal, religious
and civic organizations, permanent commercial flags, or temporary holiday decorations are not considered
ATTENTION GETTING DEVICES.
SIGN, AWNING. A sign that is printed or displayed upon an awning. An awning is a roof -like cover designed
for protection from the weather or as a decorative embellishment, which projects from a wall or roof of a
structure over a window, walkway or door, with no supports that extend to the ground.
SIGN, BALLOON. Balloons or inflated devices used as a means of directing attention to a business or service
offered.
SIGN, BANNER. A sign that is printed or displayed upon flexible material with or without frames.
SIGN, BANNER - EXHIBITION. A sign that is printed or displayed upon flexible material with or without
frames in conjunction with a special exhibit for an educational facility, government building, museum, library or
art gallery, or religious assembly.
SIGN, BILLBOARD. A sign that directs attention to a business, commodity, service, event or other activity
that is sold, offered or conducted other than on the premises where the sign is located.
SIGN, BUILDING DIRECTORY. A sign that serves as common or collective classification for a group of
persons or businesses operating in the same building or on the same lot. A BUILDING DIRECTORY SIGN may
name the persons or businesses included, but carry no other advertising matter.
SIGN, COMMUNITY EVENT. Temporary signs that announce community events and activities, including the
activities of religious assemblies, social clubs or similar groups, or special events such as fairs, rummage sales
and garage sales.
SIGN, CANOPY. A sign that is printed or displayed upon a canopy. A canopy is a roofed structure constructed
of fabric or other material placed to extend outward from the building and supported both by the structure and
by supports that extend to the ground directly under the canopy.
SIGN, CONSTRUCTION. A temporary sign that identifies an architect, contractor, subcontractor and /or
material supplier participating in construction on the property on which the sign is located and which may identify
the proposed use for the property.
SIGN, DIRECTIONAL - PARKING LOT. A sign that identifies parking lot entrances and exits, driveway
intersections, drive - through lanes, and features of a similar nature.
DEFINITIONS 125
SIGN, ELECTRONIC DISPLAY SCREEN. A sign, or portion of a sign, that displays electronic video via
television screens, plasma screens, digital screens, flat screens, LED screens, video boards, and holographic
displays.
SIGN, ELECTRONIC MESSAGE. Any sign, or portion of a sign, that uses changing lights to form a
sign message or messages in text or image form where the sequence of messages and the rate of change
is electronically programmed and can be modified by electronic processes. Time /temperature signs are not
considered ELECTRONIC MESSAGE SIGNS.
SIGN, FLASHING. A sign which contains an intermittent or sequential flashing light source used primarily to
attract attention. FLASHING SIGNS do not include ELECTRONIC MESSAGE SIGNS.
SIGN, FREESTANDING. A sign that is placed on or supported by the ground, independent of the principal
structure on the lot. FREESTANDING SIGNS may be either pole or monument signs.
SIGN, FREESTANDING MONUMENT. A freestanding sign where the base of the sign structure is on the
ground or up to a maximum of twenty -four (24) inches above grade. The monument base must be designed
as an integral part of the sign structure. The width of the top of the sign structure can be no more than one -
hundred twenty percent (120 %) of the width of the base.
SIGN, FREESTANDING POLE. A freestanding sign that is affixed, attached or erected on one (1) or two (2)
poles that is not itself an integral part of the sign.
SIGN, GHOST. A painted wall sign that remains from an earlier time or advertises the use of a building that
provides evidence of the history of the use of the building or activities of the community. A GHOST SIGN is not
considered an off - premises sign.
SIGN, GOVERNMENT. Traffic signs, legal notices, railroad crossing signs, signs regulating vehicular or
pedestrian traffic, or designating or giving direction to streets, schools, historic sites or public buildings, and
temporary emergency signs.
SIGN, HOME OCCUPATION. A sign identifying a home occupation or permitted accessory use on the
premises.
SIGN, ILLUMINATION TYPES.
A. GOOSENECK REFLECTOR. Lighting designed for mounting above or to the side of signs with a long,
shepherd hook - shaped arm to hold fixtures at a distance from the area of illumination.
B. ILLUMINATION, EXTERNAL. Lighting of a sign where lighting components are outside the sign
structure and light is directed at the sign face.
C. ILLUMINATION, INTERNAL. Lighting of a sign constructed so that all lighting components are internal
and illumination occurs as lighting is diffused through the sign face surfaces.
SIGN, MARQUEE. A permanent roof -like sign structure constructed over a building entry, with no supports
extending to the ground, where a changeable message area is part of the vertical sign fascia.
SIGN, MEMORIAL PLAQUE. A sign, tablet or plaque memorializing a historic person, event, structure or
site.
SIGN, MENUBOARD. A device that lists items for sale at an establishment with drive - through facilities.
26 I DEFINITIONS
SIGN, MOVING. A sign that, in whole or in part, rotates, elevates or in any way alters position or geometry.
MOVING SIGNS do not include clocks.
SIGN, NAMEPLATE. A sign that is affixed flat against a wall of a building or imprinted into the wall of a
building that designates the name of the building or the name and profession of one who resides or occupies
space in the building.
SIGN, NON - COMMERCIAL. A sign advocating action on a public issue or recommending a candidate for
public office.
SIGN, PARKING LOT INFORMATION. Signs that provide information on the operation of a parking lot,
such as "No Parking" or "Unauthorized users shall be towed."
SIGN, PORTABLE. A sign whose principal supporting structure is intended, by design and construction, to
rest upon the ground for support and may be easily moved or relocated for reuse. PORTABLE SIGNS include, but
are not limited to, signs mounted upon a trailer, wheeled carrier or other non - motorized mobile structure, with
wheels or with wheels removed. PORTABLE SIGNS do not include A -FRAME SIGNS.
SIGN, PROJECTING. A sign that is attached to a structure that extends beyond the surface of the structure
to which it is attached.
SIGN, PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION. A sign identifying the property management company or apartment
complex name of a multi - family dwelling.
SIGN, PUBLIC INFORMATION. Signs within an educational facility, cemetery or mausoleum, museum,
library or art gallery, and park, playground or forest reserve property that provide information on the use of the
facility, such as directional signs, trailhead locations and information kiosks.
SIGN, REAL ESTATE. A sign advertising the real estate upon which the sign is located as being for rent,
lease or sale. A REAL ESTATE SIGN can also advertise an open house.
SIGN, ROOF. A sign that is wholly erected, constructed or maintained above the roof structure or parapet of
any building with the principal support attached to the roof structure.
SIGN, SCOREBOARD. A sign that records and displays the score of a game and may include such information
as the name of the field or home team and advertising.
SIGN, SNIPE. An off - premises sign painted, pasted or otherwise affixed to any tree, rock, retaining wall,
fence, utility pole, hydrant, bridge, sidewalk, curb or street, bench or trash receptacle. Logos and labels located
on mechanical equipment, recycling bins, trash containers or dumpsters, which are part of the equipment as
manufactured and /or installed, are not SNIPE SIGNS.
SIGN, TEMPORARY OFF - PREMISES. A temporary sign that advertises a business, commodity, service,
event or other activity that is sold, offered or conducted other than on the premises where the sign is located, or
is sold, offered or conducted on the premises only incidentally, if at all.
SIGN, UNDER - AWNING. A sign that is attached to and mounted under an awning.
SIGN, UNDER - CANOPY. A sign that is attached to and mounted under a canopy.
SIGN, WALL. A sign that is mounted flat against or painted on a wall, and projects no more than twelve (12)
inches from the wall of a structure with the exposed face of the sign in a plane parallel to the face of the wall.
DEFINITIONS 27
WALL SIGN does not include WINDOW SIGN. For the purposes of this definition, a fence is not considered a wall
and WALL SIGNS are prohibited mounted on fences.
SIGN, WINDOW. A sign that is attached to, placed upon, printed on the interior or exterior of a window or
door of a building, or displayed within twelve (12) inches of a window intended for viewing from the exterior
of such a building. A WINDOW SIGN may be either permanent or temporary. Window clings are considered a
WINDOW SIGN and subject to all window sign regulations.
28 I DEFINITIONS