The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About4. Request from El Toro for Facade Improvement Program 4. CITY OF SHAKOPEE Memorandum CASE NO.: TO: Economic Development Authority Mark McNeill, Executive Director FROM: R. Michael Leek, Community Development Director SUBJECT: Request ofEl Toro for Facade Improvement loan MEETING DATE: September 16, 2008 INTRODUCTION: The City received the attached application for a loan under the Downtown and First Avenue Fac;ade Improvement Loan Program. The EDA is asked to direct staff whether to prepare a loan agreement for up to 50% of the fac;ade improvement costs. DISCUSSION: El Toro proposes renovation of their building that includes fascia, painting and other repairs. The renovation is intended to give the building a "historical authentic Mexican restaurant." Because the black and white photo copies are difficult to see, copies of the color photos will be available for viewing on-screen at the meeting. The total estimated costs of these improvements are $33,608.00. The FILP provides for loans up to one-half the cost of improvements or a maximum of $25,000 per project. In this case, one-half ofthe cost would equal $16,804.00. EI Toro also proposes sign improvements totaling $9,150.00. Were the EDA to choose to provide a loan for these improvements, one-half of the total would be $4,575.00. AL TERNA TIVES: 1. Offer and pass a motion directing staff to prepare a loan agreement for fa<;ade improvements not to exceed $16,804.00 for El Toro Restaurant at 1120 First Avenue East. 2. Offer and pass a motion directing staff to prepare a loan agreement for fa<;ade improvements not to exceed $16,804.00 and sign improvements not to exceed $4,575.00 for El Toro Restaurant at 1120 First Avenue East. 3. Deny the request for Downtown and River Corridor Fa<;ade Improvement Loan funds. 4. Table the request for additional information. DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: On Monday, August 11, 2008 the president of the Downtown Partnership, Mike Beard, and the chair of the Historic Preservation Advisory Committee, Jay Whiting, met with Community Development staff to review the FILP applications. After discussion, the committee recommended making a loan for the fac;ade improvements for EI Toro, but not the signage unless it is modified to provide for external illumination from above. H:\CC\2008\09-16\08027 EDA EI Toro.doc 1 RELATIONSHIP TO CITY GOALS: This item relates to Goal D. vibrant, resilient and stable ACTION REQUESTED: Offer and pass a motion directing staffto prepare a loan agreement with El Toro under the Fa<;ade Improvement Loan Program for fa<;ade improvements as recommended by the design review committee. /~~~A R. Michael Leek Community Development Director H:\CC\2008\09-16\08027 EDA EI Toro.doc 2 CITY OF SHAKOPEE Memorandum CASE NO.: TO: Economic Development Authority Mark McNeill, Executive Director FROM: R. Michael Leek, Community Development Director SUBJECT: Request ofEl Toro for Facade Improvement loan MEETING DATE: September 16, 2008 INTRODUCTION: The City received the attached application for a loan under the Downtown and First Avenue Fayade Improvement Loan Program. The EDA is asked to direct staff whether to prepare a loan agreement for up to 50% of the fayade improvement costs. DISCUSSION: El Toro proposes renovation of their building that includes fascia, painting and other repairs. The renovation is intended to give the building a "historical authentic Mexican restaurant." Because the black and white photo copies are difficult to see, copies of the color photos will be available for viewing on-screen at the meeting. The total estimated costs of these improvements are $33,608.00. The FILP provides for loans up to one-halfthe cost of improvements or a maximum of $25,000 per project. In this case, one-half of the cost would equal $16,804.00. El Toro also proposes sign improvements totaling $9,150.00. Were the EDA to choose to provide a loan for these improvements, one-half of the total would be $4,575.00. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Offer and pass a motion directing staff to prepare a loan agreement for fayade improvements not to exceed $16,804.00 for El Toro Restaurant at 1120 First Avenue East. 2. Offer and pass a motion directing staff to prepare a loan agreement for fayade improvements not to exceed $16,804.00 and sign improvements not to exceed $4,575.00 for EI Toro Restaurant at 1120 First A venue East. 3. Deny the request for Downtown and River Corridor Fayade Improvement Loan funds. 4. Table the request for additional information. DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: On Monday, August 11, 2008 the president of the Downtown Partnership, Mike Beard, and the chair ofthe Historic Preservation Advisory Committee, Jay Whiting, met with Community Development staff to review the FILP applications. After discussion, the committee recommended making a loan for the fayade improvements for El Toro, but not the signage unless it is modified to provide for external illumination from above. H:\CC\2008\09-16\08027 EDA EI Toro.doc 1 Estimate ... Project lEI Toro I Last Name: Gomez . First Name: Marcus JURr;q~SCN ENTERPRISES IHe, ~ ; UL~. LI Address: 1120 1 st ave E C 0 NT RAe T I NG City Shako pee State MN JEI Contracting 6806 Farciy Lane Zip Code Prior Lake, MN 55379 USA 55372 Phone: 952-440-1819 Uc# 20592745 cobbleandcover.com Mansard Mansard Construction 294 Inl ft. 294 $35.00 $10,290.00 ",-, ' w... ... Lower Tile Villa Tile on Main level of restuarant 12 $1,500.00 $18,000.00 Tower Tile Villa Tile on Tower of restaurant 2 $2,000.00 $4,000.00 Sign 3 Color Custom Sign Size: 3' x 10' with Tower Mount i $4,575.00 $9,150.00 Permit To BE Determined Electrical Electrical for Sign: To Be Determined .... ......._m..'" m . Comments: Sub-total $41,440.00 Grand Total $41,440.00 Internal Use Only Estimate . Project lEI Toro I Last Name: Gomez . First Name: Marcus JURGENSEN l=NTERDRlfl'fl HF Lii utll , U, Address: 1120 1st ave E C 0 NT RAe T I NG City Shakopee State MN JEI Contracting 6806 Farciy Lane Prior Lake, MN Zip Code 55379 USA 55372 Phone: 952-440-1819 Lic# 20592745 cobbleandcover.com Mansard Mansard Construction 2941nl ft. 200 $35.00 $7,000.00 Lower Tile Villa Tile on Main level of restuarant 11 $1,500.00 $16,500.00 ...."._om'm. . Tower Tile Villa Tile on Tower of restaurant 2 $2,000.00 $4,000.00 ................-......... ........."..-.'..." ,," Neon Sign 4' x 12' 2 Color Neon Sign installed on tower 2 $4,575.00 $9,150.00 Concrete 20' x 25' Concrete Patio 500 $13.00 $6,500.00 Demo Demolition of asphalt in patio location 500 $2.50 $1,250.00 ............"......... ........."n...... n 42" Railing Classic Railing and 48" Exit Latch with Ball Capped Posts 65 $90.00 $5,850.00 River Rock River Rock landscape around perimeter of patio 2 $300.00 $600.00 Rose Bushes Rose Bushes for landscape around patio 22 $35.00 $770.00 Permit To Be Determined Electrical Electrical for Sign: To Be Determined Comments: Sub-total $51,620.00 Grand Total $51,620.00 Internal Use Only Proiect Information Project: EL Toro Location: 1120 1st Ave E Shakopee, MN 55379 Project Description: The focus of the EI Toro building is to renovate the exterior with modern materials and colors, along with repairs for aesthetic and structure enhancement. One item being renovated are the exterior shakes that are outdated and in poor condition. The product being used to enhance the fascia is DECRA stone coated steel Villa Tiles. DECRA roof systems have a 50 year warranty, 120 mph wind speed warranty, and hail penetration warranty. The product resembles the ageless beauty of authentic villa tiles. Please see DECRA attachment for further product information. In addition to DECRA, a 4' mansard will need to be constructed for proper installation around the perimeter of building and tower. Signage is another item that needs to be focused on; we are proposing a 3' x 10' box lit sign to be installed on west and east side of the building to welcome travelers and locals driving on 1st Avenue. Painting and repair will be applied to the tower due to cracked paint and breaking plywood on the exterior of the structure. All together the exterior work will enhance the appeal of the building to fit the restaurant's food and atmosphere rather than a generic facade. EL Toro will resemble an historical authentic Mexican restaurant for decades to come. Estimate -~. Project lEI Toro I Last Name: Gomez . First Name: Marcus JURGENSEN EN-ERPRISES IN C. Address: 1120 1 st ave E C 0 N T R AC T ,I N G City Shakopee State MN JEI Contracting 6806 Farciy Lane Zip Code 55379 Prior Lake, MN USA 55372 Phone: 952-440-1819 Lic# 20592745 cobbleandcover.com Item i)esC:ription Quantity Unit Price Amount Mansard Mansard Construction 230 Inl ft. 230 $35.00 $8,050.00 - - - Lower Tile Villa Tile on Main level of restaurant 11 $1,500.00 $16,500.00 Tower Tile Villa Tile on Tower of restaurant 2 $2,000.00 $4,000.00 Sign 3 Color Custom Sign Sizes 3' xl 0' with Tower Mount 2 $4,575.00 $9,150.00 Tower Repair Repair Plywood and Supports on Tower 4 $225.00 $900.00 ----- Paint Paint Front of Building, Tower, and Back of Building 1,512 $2.75 $4,158.00 Permit To Be Determined ----. - ,-- - . - ~ ~ . u_ Electrical Electrical for Sign: To Be Determined - - -- -- -- -- -- n_... ._ _. Comments: Sub-total $42,758.00 Any questions or concerns please call Chase at 612-636-4199 - ---- Grand Total $42,758.00 Internal Use Only -------- --~_._- ---~- ------ - - 1 \ ! I I I I I ,- . n,l ,.(f. ~~,~~...,.'!'~~-'MliI'- ~~- DECRA's , Villa Tile cOlnbines I the superior performance of steel with the classic beauty! elegance and architectural detail of an old world Italian tile+ Durable and lightweight! I Villa Tile requires I I little to no I DECRA maintenance and I Stone Coated Steel Roofing Systems is walkable+ I ____~_._ ~__________.______ __n _____ Available Colors I I I I \ Capn' Clay Rustico Clay I Villa Tile: I I 25.2 panels per square 1 Five unique color blends I Walkable barrel tile profile Amalji Sand Pompeii Ash 1 I All DECRA . profiles feature: I Transferable 50-year limited warranty I I I i 120 mph wind warranty Freeze/thaw resistant I Venetian Gold (steel has 0% water absorption) I Lightweight ~~ I .rifJjl-f2? Class A fire-rated material ~:~~~~ . ~:.~:p~:..:.~ - .k .:!){f/!!/:~~~~~2 Class 4 impact resistance to UL 2218 I JFp.~ -...P:...::...-.....;;..----- ~ ~ :".,~ .... .J~,,*'~Y' 1 ~:-"I'::'-----_. ~ ~ :" ~..,~ ~#.. - ------ ' ;,;#t;f:!~~ ------~ i ~~d~ ~ -- .... - -; ''!E/i.~ ~;t,..~~ . . I - _.~*;~#' .... ~~~~.-*- ... ~:!ff/ffi!.#;#' ~~..'*;~.#R/ /~a~..t..,9'~ ,," ~"?k-J!:'I>-t?" ."' /1/'if~~~~~'#-' -\ ~;:.;.;,'r:~~ '\ ~?.:..~~.. . '\ ..~~ .', . .'- '- ' , . ~~, .... '"\. \' ",,' .":'- .~ ~'- ~ ~"-.~:,,,_ - .~--~--__" '. '. .......)i 877.GO.DECRA ~ ~~J;U;;_i.ji___-<J......J>..:~ DECRA Stone Coated Steel Roofing Systems - - , I , I , I I I i I eXIcan es auran --- ---'-~_._-_..- - "'-------" . -- . I I - .. ,--~ r ~ F I I I I El Taro, Side (Before) I \ I I I ~ ll~_~l ....... I J -~, ~.- I I I I I \ ~-'-' --.- ~'-,-' --.-..'-' -' -"-'" ~'-~-' ---,_. --.->-.....--.- - -. -- - -~ _.. c: - ~. ....-.. - ,.......~ .'."-" lW-.;;.l.iOlo ~ ---...,. - ...... - ~::i- I-m- .-..." " , ~ " .-. ., =~~~ -';'..- -............ ~.iie ------ _.. _h ...._~ ._-..---" - -------~~::-._"_.,";,..";;..-;:~ ~:.~ ::: --~~~.~.,~~._,-_._~-~~~:'!: ~"::=--- -:---::~:;~~.~ :-"":. ~". .=::~~-~:;:;~- ~~ ::"~c:.~ ---" ~ -~._~-.::: ~ ~--~. ~ ~-~--=.=-:::.~..- EI Taro, Front (Before) ~ 't M - .. I I ! i I I I I I I [ ~~_.......~- I ~~ -'i.>"' """",",-_ , ~-~ <if-':';;'- ~-~ - - - - - I - "'~ "- .- - -- - - j t .- - ~ - - _.. ~- . _.- "<_....... .-- L ~':'~~E" ;... - -... ~^"''--'C'''-''''',,::~:,::,~=,, ~~~ .. ..., ~ '-"'. l<lO_U =.::'::'::. =-~~ ~._--. -__;.;;c -_. ~'~~':':.- - ..........iir...~.;1 EI Toro, Front (After) - - -- --~ "" _ """,1;".. Il.ll _ --'-1 EI Lara, Savage I \ I Mark Noble "" w,,,, From: JEI Contracting [jeicontracting@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, June 17, 20084:58 PM To: Michael Leek; Mark Noble Subject: J.E.I Contracting: EI Taro Facade Specifics and Information Attachments: EI Toro.zip Hello Mark and Michael, Attached are the El Toro specifics. You will see pictures of current and proposed exteriors. The estimate for the project along with the project description. Material information and the Box lite sign design. I have also attached a picture of the recently finished exterior J.E.! Contracting renovated for the Savage restaurant location El Loro. I will be there in the next couple of days to drop off a sample of the DECRA Roof System. If there is anything else you need please call or e-mail. Thank you, Chase Jurgensen JEI Contracting Lakeville,MN 55044 Tel:952-469-1315 Fax:952-469-4610 www.JEIContracting.com 06/18/2008 --~-----_._- ----------.-.------ -'-.-'--- ------ ____'_._n__ I - -....... - - ~ 'W - _e"o""'.".'._ -.- - -- ---- ~w . . , I ! I I I I I I ~ ,.,".!P I t I,,' l!Z i';?; lIT I EI Lara, Savage I I I I I I I I I -~~----------- - ------------ , ! I I t.~~ I " ~. I I, ........., - ~ ,;:Ji I , . r I I r I I L I ! I I EI Taro, Side (Before) I I I I I \ I [ I I , I I I I I I I I \ I I -.---- ---- - ...~-. ~.~ -.. ~- ~.+~ ''''':''''., """;;''';;'~ I .,. -"-- ... _... I - ".-... '--.. I: o;t6; -::__..._ _ "''''''''""..V' a 'f ~""'~- ~~~'>>~,;.C~ ~ ~ -~ ...- . -\~'--' ........ '" ~ , .- ...... ~ ~ ---- - __.. ~_ __ _ ::' __. ~::c_~~_~__.__ A ___H_'__" - .-^'.- ~= -- ~-~.~- EI Taro, Front (Before) ~ ~ I ~.... I I J I -....- /ii.:.........."1WIIRr ...~ ---~--- 'r ".~~. r'--,....~ ~ ------... iii -- - ~-1:::~~~~ j I -. ~ ' j .- I .. - .- =.. - ... -- " . I "'._ - _..-- ,- - -.- I ~~.~_.=:::::::;;:: ".-~6>,=:::_~';;;;:; ~ ";.-___,~ ~ - ~ _._~-~------~~ - .&;' "~~~-"';;:"':: ,'.;'.:...,;';' ~<...:..'_:.:...' ..". ' EI Taro, Front (After)